The US Men’s Curling team made history in South Korea while most of the United States slept early Saturday morning, winning its first ever gold medal in the sport. But the moment where the victory was perhaps its sweetest was soon made a bit awkward by a mixup the team soon noticed: they were given the wrong medals on the podium! As it turns out, each Olympic medal is engraved with the name of the sport the medal was awarded in. And the US team was given the gold medal for women’s curling, not men’s. We’ve got a great pic of the team trying to figure out what happened.